A teoria da regulação e o enfoque setorial: o papel de destaque da agricultura
Keywords:
theory of regulation, agricultura sector, technical progress, working processAbstract
This paper presents a critical view of the so called French Theory of Regulation (FTR), followed by an analysis of its application to the agricultural sector. There is no intention to cover all aspects involved in such a broad range theory, but only to point its basic elements. It tries to show why this theory is so enduring as an alternative theoretical view in the academic debate. It presents also a short analysis of the main ways the FTR deals with the economic sectors, before specifically considering the case of the agricultural sector. The criticisms aim mainly at the theoretical proposition formulated by Lacroix e
Mollard (1994), based on the concept of rapport salarial that has led, among others, to flawed analogies with the industrial sector concerning the evolution of the working process. The agricultural sector can not be compared to the industrial one in this respect because of its natural peculiarities, which prevents the agricultural working process to be decomposed as in the industrial sector.
Downloads
References
AFFAIRE, G & BOYER, R. (cds.). Lajjmnde transformation de Bagriculture: lectures conventionnalistes et regulationnistes. Economica- INRA, 1995.
AFFAIRE, G. Croissance et crise en agriculture. In BOYER & SALFIARD (eds.), La theorie de la regulation: Vetat de savoirs. Paris: Fa Decouvert, 1995. 565p.
BARTOFI, P & BOUFET, D. Conditions d'une approche en termes de regulation sectorielle. Cahiers d'Economie et Sociologie Rurales, n. 17, p. 7-38, 1990.
BOYER, R. & CORIAT, B. Marx, la technique et la dynamique longue de Vaccumulation. Paris: CEPREMAP, 1983.
BOYER, R. La theorie de la regulation: une analyse critique. Paris: La Decouvert, coll. Agalma, 1986.
BOYER, R. Les problematiques de la regulation face aux specificites sectorielles. Perspectives ouvertes par la these de Pierre Bartoli et Daniel Boulet. Cahiers dEconomie et Sociologie Rurales, n. 17, Paris: INRA/ESR, 1990.
BOYER, R. Eagriculture, terrain de choix pour les recherches en economie industrielle. Cahiers d'Economie et Sociologie Rumles, n. 29, Paris: INRA,1993.
BOYER, R. Secteurs, regions et modes de regulation. In: ALLAIRE, G. &
BOYER, R. (eds.), La jjmnde transformation de Vagriculture. Paris; Economica-INRA, 1995.
BOYER, R. & SALLIARD, Y. Un precis de la regulation. In BOYER & SALLIARD (eds.), La theorie de la regulation: Letat de savoirs. Paris: La Decouvert, 1995a. 565p.
BOYER, R. La theorie de la regulation a 20 ans. In: BOYER & SALLIARD (eds.), La theorie de la regulation: Letat desSavoirs. Paris: La Decouvert, 1995b. 565p.
CANUTO, O. Crftica ao arcabou^o regulacionista. Anais daANPEC, 1988. CLIO, J. Regulation et histoire; je faime, moi non plus. In: BOYER & SALLIARD (eds.), La theorie de la regulation: Letat de savoirs. Paris: La Decouvert, 1995. 565p.
DOSI, G. & ORSENIGO, L. Co-ordination and transformation: an overview of structures, behaviours and change in evolutionary environments. In DOSI et alii (eds.), Technical change and economic theory. London: Frances
Pinter, 1988.
FRIEDMAN, H. Changes in the international division of labour; agri-food complexes ands export agriculture. 7w: FRIEDLAND, H., BUTTEL, E H. & RUDY, A.P (orgs.), Towards a newpolitical economy to agriculture. EUA: Westview Press, 1991.
HABERMAS, J. A crise de legitimagdo no capitalismo tardio. Biblioteca Tempo Universitario. Tempo Brasileiro, 1994. 176p.
HENIN, S. Lequilibre agriculture-industrie. Encyclopedie Frangaise, Tome XIII, Agriculture-Industrie, Paris, 1962.
INGRAM, D. Habermas e adialetica da razdo. 2a ed. Brasilia: Ed. UnB, 1987. 297p.
JACOBS, J. The economy ofthe cities. NY: Randon House, 1969.
JESSOP. Regulation theories in retrospect and prospect. Economy and Society, v. 19, n. 2, p. 153-216, 1990.
KENNEY, M. et alii. Agriculture in U.S. fordism. In FRIEDLAND, H.,
BUTTEL, F. H, & RUDY, A. P. (orgs.),Towards a newpolitical economy to agriculture. EUA: Westview Press, 1991.
KLOPPENBURG JR., J. R. First the seed, the political economy ofplant biotechnology. Cambridge NY: University Press, 1988. 349p.
LACROIX, A. Transformations du proces de travail agricole; incidences de Lindustrialisation sur les conditions de travailpaysannes. These de Doctorat, IREP/INRA, 1981.
LACROIX, A & MOLLARD, A. L'approche sectorielle de la regulation. Grenoble: INRA, 1993,
LACROX, A & MOLLARD, A. Lapproche sectorielle de la regulation: une problematique a partir de I'agriculture. In: ALLAIRE, G. & BOYER, R. (eds.), La jjmnde transformation de Vagriculture.. Paris: Economica-INRA, 1994.
LORDON, E Formaliser la dynamique et les crises regulationnistes. In:
BOYER & SALLIARD (eds.),L« theorie de la regulation: Vetat de savoirs.Paris: La Decouvert, 1995. 565p.
MARRAMAO, G. Voder e secularizagdo. Sao Paulo: Ed. Unesp, 1995. 347p.
ORLEAN, A. (ed.). Analyse economique des conventions. Coll. Paris: "Economie'TUF, 1994.
PAGE, B & WALKER, R. From setdement to fordism: the agroindustrial revolution in the American Midwest. Economic Geography, v. 67, n. 4, p. 281-314, 1991.
POSSAS, M. L., SALLES-FILHO, S. L. M. & SILVEIRA, J. M da. An evolutionary approach to technological innovation in agriculture: some preliminary remarks. In: EUNETICS Conference. Strasbourg, 1994.
POSSAS, M. L. Cntica a teoria de Anais da ANEEC, 1988.
ROMEIRO, A. R. Revolu^ao industrial e mudamja tecnologica na agricultura europeia. Revista de Histdria, USP, n. 123/24, 1990/91.
ROMEIRO, M. L. Progresso tecnico, organiza^ao da produ^ao e condi^oes de trabalho na agricultura. Revista Brasileira de Economia, FGV, v. 46, n. 3, jul-set. 1992.
ROMEIRO, M. L. Agricultura e agroindiistria: perspectivas de novas configura96es. Revista de Economia PoUtica, v. 14, n. 3, jul-set. 1994.
RONDE, P Progress technique etstrategies defirmes. Strasbourg, ULP: Universite Louis Pasteur. These de Doctorat de Sciences Economiques. 1992. 431p.
SADOULET, E. & DE JANVRY, A. Quantitative development analysis. The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1995.
SILVEIRA, J. M da. Economia das conve^oes e coordena^ao economica. Revista Economia e Sociedade 3, Campinas: IE, 1994.
VEIGA, J. E. Economia poHtica da emergente transi^o agroambiental - o caso dos EUA. Relatorio de Pesquisa. USP-EEA-PROCAM, 996,mimeo. 152p. (vol I).
WALKER, R. Regulation and flexible specialization as theories of capitalist development. Spatial practices: critical explorations in social/spacial theory. Sage publications, apud. VEIGA J. op.cit, 1996.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 1997 Ademar Ribeiro Romeiro, José Maria J. da Silveira
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
By submitting an article, the author authorizes its publication and attests that it has not been submitted to any other journal. The original article is considered final. Articles selected for publication are proofread for grammatical and orthographic errors. The journal does not pay rights for published articles. The Institute of Economic Research from the School of Economics, Business and Accounting of the University of São Paulo (Instituto de Pesquisas Econômicas da Faculdade de Economia, Administração e Contabilidade da Universidade de São Paulo) owns the journal's copyright.
